1) Welcome & Attendance a) Recognition of New Panel Members ~ Welcome to our new panel members and thank you for agreeing to serve on the panel: Diem-My Bui (UIC), John Hooker (ISU), David Johnson (WIU), Dana Kinzy (UIUC, and Sandy Pensoneau-Conway (SIUC). ~ Thank you to outgoing panel members for your service on the panel: Kristi McDuffie (UIUC) and Andrew Wilson (HC). 2) Course Review & Decision Options: a) Anything we need to discuss before looking at the submitted courses? b) Course Decision Options: Quick Accepts, Accepted, Conditional Approval, Not Enough Info, & Return Courses For Panel Review 7 New Courses 3 Resubmitted New Courses 23 Ongoing Review Courses 10 Resubmitted Ongoing Review Courses 43 Total Courses
New Courses IAICode: C1900 Institution: Southwestern Illinois College Institution Course Number/Name: ENG 101: Rhetoric & Composition I Final Decision: Approved
IAICode: C1900 Institution: University of Illinois at Springfield Institution Course Number/Name: CAP 111: Honors Composition Final Decision: Approved
IAICode: C1900 Institution: Shawnee Community College Institution Course Number/Name: ENG 0110: English Composition I with Review Final Decision: Not Enough Information
IAICode: C1901R Institution: University of Illinois at Springfield Institution Course Number/Name: CAP 115: Interdisciplinary Writing Final Decision: Not Enough Information
IAICode: C2900 Institution: Black Hawk College Institution Course Number/Name: SPEC 101 (Online): Principles of Speech Communication (Online) Final Decision: Approved
IAICode: C2900 Institution: College of DuPage Institution Course Number/Name: SPEEC 1100 (ONLINE): Fundamentals of Speech Communication (ONLINE) Final Decision: Approved
IAICode: C2900 Institution: Southwestern Illinois College Institution Course Number/Name: Comm 151 (Online): Comm 151 (Online) Final Decision: Approved
Resubmitted New Courses IAICode: C1900R Institution: Generations College Institution Course Number/Name: Comp 1020: College Composition II Final Decision: Approved
IAICode: C2900 Institution: Truman College (Harry S) (CCC) Institution Course Number/Name: Speech 101 (Online): Fundamentals of Speech Communication (Online) Final Decision: Approved
IAICode: C2900 Institution: Elgin Community College Institution Course Number/Name: CMS 101: Fundamentals of Speech Final Decision: Approved
Ongoing Review Courses IAICode: C1900 Institution: Moraine Valley Community College Institution Course Number/Name: COM 101: Composition I Final Decision: Approved
IAICode: C1900 Institution: Prairie State College Institution Course Number/Name: ENG 101: Composition I Final Decision: Conditionally Approved
IAICode: C1900 Institution: Parkland College Institution Course Number/Name: ENG 101: Composition I Final Decision: Not Enough Information
IAICode: C1900 Institution: Eastern Illinois University Institution Course Number/Name: ENG 1091G: College Composition I, Honors Final Decision: Not Enough Information
IAICode: C1900 Institution: Waubonsee Community College Institution Course Number/Name: ENG 101: First-Year Composition I Final Decision: Conditionally Approved
IAICode: C1900 Institution: Spoon River College Institution Course Number/Name: ENG 101: Composition I Final Decision: Not Enough Information
IAICode: C1900 Institution: Sauk Valley Community College Institution Course Number/Name: ENG 101: Composition I Final Decision: Not Enough Information
IAICode: C1900 Institution: Roosevelt University Institution Course Number/Name: ENG 101: Expository Writing Final Decision: Not Enough Information
IAICode: C1900 Institution: John Wood Community College Institution Course Number/Name: ENG 101: Rhet and Comp I Final Decision: Not Enough Information
IAICode: C1901R Institution: University of Illinois at Chicago Institution Course Number/Name: ENGL 161: Academic Writing II Final Decision: Conditionally Approved
IAICode: C1901R Institution: Rend Lake College Institution Course Number/Name: ENGL 1102: Rhetoric and Composition II Final Decision: Not Enough Information
IAICode: C1901R Institution: Olive-Harvey College (CCC) Institution Course Number/Name: ENGLISH 102: Composition Final Decision: Not Enough Information
IAICode: C1901R Institution: Northeastern Illinois University Institution Course Number/Name: ENGL 102: Writing II Final Decision: Not Enough Information
IAICode: C1901R Institution: Chicago State University Institution Course Number/Name: ENG 1240: Writer's Workshop II Final Decision: Not Enough Information
IAICode: C1901R Institution: Eastern Illinois University Institution Course Number/Name: ENG 1092G: College Composition II, Honors Final Decision: Not Enough Information
IAICode: C1901R Institution: Spoon River College Institution Course Number/Name: ENG 102: Composition II Final Decision: Not Enough Information
IAICode: C2900 Institution: Black Hawk College Institution Course Number/Name: SPEC 101: Principles of Speech Communication Final Decision: Approved
IAICode: C2900 Institution: Benedictine University Institution Course Number/Name: COMM 1110: Speech Communication Final Decision: Not Enough Information
IAICode: C2900 Institution: College of DuPage Institution Course Number/Name: SPEEC 1100: Fundamentals of Speech Communication Final Decision: Approved
IAICode: C2900 Institution: Southwestern Illinois College Institution Course Number/Name: COMM 151: Fundamentals of Public Speaking Final Decision: Approved
IAICode: C2900 Institution: Sauk Valley Community College Institution Course Number/Name: COM 131: Introduction to Oral Communication Final Decision: Approved
IAICode: C2900 Institution: Sauk Valley Community College Institution Course Number/Name: COM 131 online: Introduction to Oral Communication Final Decision: Conditionally Approved
IAICode: C2900 Institution: John Wood Community College Institution Course Number/Name: CMN 101: Intro to Speech Final Decision: Not Enough Information
Resubmitted Ongoing Review Courses IAICode: C1901R Institution: Southeastern Illinois College Institution Course Number/Name: ENG 122: Rhetoric & Composition II Final Decision: Returned
IAICode: C1901R Institution: Malcolm X College (CCC) Institution Course Number/Name: ENGLISH 102: Composition Final Decision: Not Enough Information
IAICode: C1901R Institution: Daley College (Richard J.) (CCC) Institution Course Number/Name: ENGLISH 102: Composition Final Decision: Not Enough Information
IAICode: C1901R Institution: Parkland College Institution Course Number/Name: ENG 102: Composition II Final Decision: Not Enough Information
IAICode: C1901R Institution: Lewis & Clark Community College Institution Course Number/Name: ENGL 132: First Year English II Final Decision: Returned
IAICode: C1901R Institution: Roosevelt University Institution Course Number/Name: ENG 102: Argumentation Analysis Research Final Decision: Not Enough Information
IAICode: C1901R Institution: College of Lake County Institution Course Number/Name: ENG 126: Advanced Composition: Sci. & Tech. Comm. Final Decision: Conditionally Approved
IAICode: C1901R Institution: Shawnee Community College Institution Course Number/Name: ENG 112: English Composition Final Decision: Not Enough Information
IAICode: C1901R Institution: John Wood Community College Institution Course Number/Name: ENG 102: Rhetoric and Composition II Final Decision: Conditionally Approved
IAICode: C2900 Institution: Carl Sandburg College Institution Course Number/Name: SPE 120: Intro Public Speaking Final Decision: Approved 4) Panel Business a) Are changes needed for any of the panel’s current descriptors and/or course approval criteria? - Panel discussed the policy and criteria for in-person classes using video recorded speeches. The decision was made that the same criteria required for fully online speech courses should also be applied to F2F courses using a recorded speech. - Panel discussed how institutions are demonstrating that the panel-required competencies are being developed and met within the writing courses. It was also discussed throughout course review as well as at the end of the meeting. While no changes or clarifications regarding these expectations were made to the panel’s course approval criteria, members agreed that this can be demonstrated or evidenced through the assignment descriptions and weekly topical outline. Malinda expressed concern about determining how much information will be expected, and what must explicitly be stated without being viewed by submitting institutions as panel overreach, going forward given that the competencies are fairly new and this was not required in the past. IAI Leadership expects that Krista will get several questions from institutions about this as well. The panel will likely need to revisit this topic again in the fall. - There were brief discussions about the following: > Submission of master syllabi (most likely when it’s a new course). The panel’s course approval criteria already includes the following statement so no changes are needed at this time: "The panel submission requires a representative instructor syllabus. Submitting a generic syllabus is acceptable if it includes all of the requirements below; otherwise, the submitted syllabus must be a current one used by an instructor." > Request to remind institutions of the following: * Per the panel’s course approval criteria, 1) all submitted writing course syllabi must include the required C and D statements, and 2) The weekly topical outline must go beyond chapter numbers and titles and be detailed by including topics covered, readings, assignment details, etc. * The panel prefers to have all required information, including assignment details, within the submitted representative instructor syllabus rather than submitting additional documents / addendum for the panel to review. b) Outstanding / ongoing topics from previous panel meeting(s) c) Updates d) Other discussion items from panel members e) Next meeting(s): i) Fall '23 = Friday, November 3rd, 2023, at 10:00 to 2:30 pm, via Zoom, in-person TBD/Normal, IL ii) Spring '24 = TBD at Fall '23 Meeting _____________________________________ Panel Approval Ratio Panel: [GenEd] Communication Panel Semester Fall 2022 _____________________________________ Ongoing Courses = 20 New Courses = 14 Total Courses = 34 _____________________________________ Approved Ratio = 55.88% Conditional Approved Ratio = 5.88% Approved & Conditional Ratio = 61.76% Non-Approved Ratio = 38.24% Total Ratio = 100.00% _____________________________________ |